| Platinum | Tim's Pizza East |
| Gold | Geraldi's |
| Silver | Guido's Pizza |
| Bronze | Wood Stone Craft Pizza |
| Top Pick | Marley's Chicago Style Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville |
| Top Pick | Pizza Navona |
| Top Pick | Us Pizza Company |
| Top Pick | Wicked Wood Fired Pizza |
| Tony's NY Style Pizza |