| Platinum | Six Twelve Coffeehouse and Bar |
| Gold | Tontitown Winery |
| Silver | Crisis Brewery |
| Bronze | Pinpoint Fayetteville |
| Top Pick | Foghorn's Wings Burgers & More |
| Top Pick | Fossil Cove |
| Top Pick | JJ's Grill |
| Top Pick | Maxine's Tap Room |
| Top Pick | Tony's NY Style Pizza |
| Top Pick | Wood Stone Craft Pizza |